HOME BIRTH: IS IT RIGHT FOR ME?

You can see listings for home birth providers in the Chicago-area by choosing “I’M LOOKING FOR A HOME BIRTH PROVIDER” in the drop down menu here.

 

The information on this page will help you think through whether home birth is the right choice for you. The more you learn about your options, the better you’ll feel about the choice you finally make. There’s a lot to consider, including the practical and emotional advantages and disadvantages of each setting, the scientific evidence on outcomes, how to find a provider, and what other options you have.

OVERVIEW

While still uncommon in the US, more and more American women are choosing to birth at home. If you are low-risk and if natural childbirth is a high priority for you, you might want to consider home birth. When you plan a home birth, you are much less likely to have any interventions than low risk women who plan hospital births — including cesarean birth, induction, episiotomy, epidural and other pain medication. A home birth could also be a good choice if you would feel more relaxed laboring in a familiar place with the people you have chosen to be there, since feeling relaxed can help you labor more effectively.

There are other practical and emotional advantages and disadvantages of home birth that you’ll also want to take into account as you decide whether home birth is right for you. (Scroll down to see Considerations.)

In particular, you need to understand what the scientific evidence says about home birth safety so you can weigh the risks and benefits of a home birth for yourself. The evidence on home birth safety in the US is not conclusive. None of the studies meets the highest standards for scientific evidence. And while some studies suggest that home birth attended by a licensed home birth midwife is as safe as hospital birth (assuming you are low risk), others suggest that hospital birth is safer. (Scroll down to The Research Says to see a summary of the research. You can also go directly to a more in-depth discussion of the evidence by clicking here.)

If you decide you might be interested in home birth, take the time to find a provider who is right for you. There are several licensed home birth providers in the Chicago area and most of them serve a fairly wide area, so you should have several providers to choose from.  (Scroll down to see Choosing a Home Birth Provider.)

And finally, if you decide home birth isn’t quite right for you, you have other good options. (Scroll down to see Alternatives to Consider.)

CONSIDERATIONS

Each birth setting has advantages and disadvantages. Different people will weigh those differently. You need to sort through what matters most to you. Here are some considerations that may help you decide whether home birth is or isn’t right for you.

RIGHT FOR YOU? NOT RIGHT FOR YOU?

PHILOSOPHY OF CARE

Home birth practitioners see normal birth as a natural, healthy life event that is safest and most satisfying without routine interventions. They expect you to be a partner in your own care.

If you view birth as being best safeguarded by medical technology and if you are comfortable with the use of routine interventions to actively manage labor and birth, a hospital birth might be a better fit for you.

SURROUNDINGS

You may find it very comforting to labor at home in familiar surroundings. You will have complete control over your physical surroundings: you can set up your space exactly as you want it.

You may find it very comforting to labor at home in familiar surroundings. You will have complete control over your physical surroundings: you can set up your space exactly as you want it.

FEELINGS

You may feel safer and more relaxed at home, which can make birth easier, faster and less painful. If the idea home birth just feels right to you, listening to your intuition can be empowering and liberating.

You or your partner may feel safer in a hospital or birth center where high-tech support is nearby. You may feel anxious making a choice so outside the norm. You may feel judged by people around you. If something goes wrong, you may blame yourself or feel blamed by others more than if you had chosen a hospital birth.

MANAGING PAIN

You may find it easier to manage pain at home because you can move, eat and drink, bathe and choose the position you labor in. You will have privacy and control. You can rent a birthing tub to use at home. Laboring in water can be an effective way to manage pain.

You cannot have an epidural at home. If you decide in labor that you want an epidural, you will have to transfer to the hospital.

WHO TAKES CARE OF YOU

In Illinois, only certified nurse midwives (CNMs) and doctors are licensed to attend home births. Licensed home birth doctors and midwives have extensive training in their field. They follow the midwifery model of care, which is personal, holistic and family-centered. Your licensed home birth doctor or midwife is skilled at helping you labor safely and effectively and manage pain without medications. He or she is also trained to recognize when you might need to transfer to the hospital.

Depending on where you live, you may not be able to find a doctor or certified nurse midwife (CNM) who attends home births in your area. Midwives who are not CNMs cannot practice legally in Illinois. Licensed home birth practitioners only care for low risk women. If you are not low risk, you may not be eligible for a home birth.

SUPPORT IN LABOR

Your midwife or doctor will come to your home when you go into active labor and stay with you until several hours after your baby is born. She or he will be available to you throughout. You have complete control over who else is with you during labor and birth (family, friends, doula).

If you have a very long labor, the people who are there to support you (family, friends, doula) may get tired. There will be no staff on hand to take over for them.

POLICIES & ROUTINES

When you birth at home, there are no rules or routines to limit your choices. You will have freedom to eat and drink, move instinctually in labor and deliver in the position that feels right to you. Home birth practitioners are very patient and do not generally impose time limits on your labor.

-

INTERVENTION RATES

When you plan a home birth, you are much less likely to have any interventions than low risk women who plan hospital births — including c-section, induction, episiotomy, and pain medication. C-section rates for women who plan home birth average are very low.

-

SAFETY

If you are low-risk and attended by a well-trained provider, some research studies suggest that planning a home birth can be as safe as planning a hospital birth. While there are other research studies suggesting that a hospital birth is safer, the risk is very low in both settings. If you read more about the research and decide that you feel safe at home, home birth could be a good fit you. (See "The Research Says" below.) You and your baby won’t be exposed to the illnesses found in the hospital. If you need to transport to the hospital in labor, it is not usually an emergency. When an emergency does arise, home birth providers are trained to stabilize you and your baby as you head to the hospital.

Even if you are low-risk, some of the research studies suggest that planning a hospital birth is safer. If you read more about the research and conclude that you would feel safer in a birth center or hospital, then home birth might not be a good fit for you. (See "The Research Says" below.) If you are not low risk, home birth will be less safe for you than birth in a hospital or birth center. If there are no licensed providers who serve your area, home birth may be less safe for you. In Illinois, only Certified Nurse Midwives and doctors are licensed to attend home births. Unlicensed providers -- even if they are well-trained -- may be reluctant to transport to the hospital because they are practicing illegally. This could increase the risk to you of planning a home birth. If you need to drive very far to get to the hospital for back-up care, then planning a home birth may be less safe for you.

CONTINUITY OF CARE

Home birth practitioners do not have shifts and will stay with you throughout labor.

If you decide you want pain medication or if your labor becomes complicated, you will have to transfer care to the hospital. Although a few home birth practitioners have hospital privileges and can continue to be involved in your care when you transfer, most do not.

GETTING THERE & TRANSFER

As labor gets underway, you can stay right where you are.

If you decide you want pain medication or if your labor becomes complicated, you will have be driven to the hospital while you’re in labor. Transporting during active labor can be painful, disruptive and upsetting.

PRENATAL CARE

Prenatal visits tend to be long and relaxed, with plenty of time to talk and ask questions. You may be able to bring other children with you. Some home birth providers offer prenatal visits in your home.

If home prenatal visits are not an option, you may have to travel quite far to get to your prenatal appointments.

AFTER DELIVERY

Unless you or your baby has any complications, you will be left undisturbed to bond with your baby. You will not be separated from your baby even for the newborn wellness exam. After your baby is born, you can settle in to your new routine with no interruptions. You do not need to drive home with a new baby. You can have as many friends and family as you want come to meet the new baby. Your home birth practitioner will come back to check up on you and your baby in the early days after your baby is born.

You will need to arrange your own support after the birth; you won’t have nurses checking up on you every 4 hours. If you want to have the first day or two to give your new baby undivided attention, but you have small children at home, you might consider a birth center or hospital birth.

COST

Home birth is cheaper than hospital birth.

Not all health insurance covers home birth. You may have to pay more out-of-pocket for home birth than for hospital or birth center birth.

THE RESEARCH SAYS . . .

The evidence on the safety of home birth in the US is not conclusive. Some studies show that hospital birth is safer for low-risk women than planned home birth. Others show that home birth is as safe as birth in the hospital IF:

 

  • you are low-risk,
  • you choose a well-trained, licensed provider ,
  • you have ready access to back-up care if complications arise.

Because the safety of home birth in the US is controversial, it’s important that you understand the research and take responsibility for balancing the risks and benefits of a home birth in your own case.

 

You can learn more about the research here.

CHOOSING A HOME BIRTH PROVIDER

Once you decide that you’re interested in having a home birth, plan to meet face-to-face with a few home birth providers. You are looking for someone you trust. This is also a good way to test whether your choice holds up as you begin to learn more.

Here are some prompts you may find helpful before and after your appointments. Pick the ones that seem important to you.

General questions for your provider:

 

  • What kind of birth do you see the most often?
  • What part of your job do you enjoy the most? What are you best at?
  • What do you think makes pregnancy and birth safer?
  • How likely is it that you would be the one actually attending my birth, and who else might end up being there?
  • How would you handle the situation if you recommended something to me and I ended up choosing a different option?
  • What kind of prenatal testing do you require? Recommend?
  • What do you do if I go past my due date?
  • Will a tub be available and do you ever use it for labor? For delivery?
  • What is your cesarean birth rate?
  • What can I expect to pay out of pocket?

 

Questions specific to home birth:

 

  • What is your certification, education and legal standing in the state where I live?
  • What kind of health conditions would exclude me from delivering at home?
  • Do you ever attend VBAC, multiple or breech deliveries? Why or why not? (These conditions are higher risk and have a significantly increased neonatal mortality rates for home birth.)
  • Where would we go for a non-emergency transfer to the hospital? And in an emergency? How long does it take to get there?
  • What kind of arrangement/relationship do you have with the physicians at the hospital where you transfer?
  • How often have you transferred and how has it gone in the past?
  • Do you have prenatal visits at home or in your office?
  • Who else comes with you to births, and what is their training?
  • If you could not attend my birth, who would deliver my baby? How often does that happen?
  • What happens if I go past my due date?
  • How long will you stay after the baby arrives?

 

Questions to ask yourself after an appointment:

 

  • Did you feel at ease?
  • Did you feel rushed?
  • Did you feel listened to?
  • Were your questions answered?
  • Did the provider ask your permission before touching you?
  • How did your partner feel?

It can take awhile to get to know and trust your provider. If after several months you start to have doubts, don’t hesitate to make a change.

ALTERNATIVES

If you’re attracted to the idea of a home birth but you or your partner are anxious about safety, a good alternative for you might be a midwife-led birth center. You could also consider having your baby with a midwife in the hospital.

STILL NOT SURE?